The analysis in PDF:

From-Resistance-to-Revolution-The-Case-for-a-Peoples-Party1

From Resistance to Revolution
Summary
The majority of Americans are progressive and want a major new political party.
Despite Bernie Sanders’ monumental efforts to reform the Democratic Party, it remains
firmly in neoliberal control. The Democratic Party has made it clear that it will not be
the vehicle for the political revolution. Now the choice is ours: do we submit to the
establishment parties and allow the spiral into oligarchy to continue? Or do we form a
party for the progressive majority?
Affiliation with the major parties has been declining for a decade and there are now far
more independents than Democrats or Republicans. Trump’s attacks on working people
and Bernie’s immense efforts to bring people into the Democratic Party should be
expanding the party. But Gallup figures reveal an alarming trend: since the general
election, affiliation with the Democratic Party is declining while the Republican Party is
holding steady, even growing slightly.
Despite the collective efforts to expand the Democratic party, more and more people
are leaving and becoming independents. The American people are leading the way to an
independent alternative. Instead of struggling against the progressive current in an
effort to save an establishment party, we should swim with the progressive current and
create the new party that most Americans want.
As Americans grow more progressive, they realize that the Democratic Party doesn’t
represent them and are not inspired to vote. Only a new party built on the progressive
views of the majority can inspire the turnout necessary to defeat Trump and his agenda.
Third parties have historically led progressive change throughout U.S. history. Bernie
Sanders has an overwhelmingly high favorability with Democrats and independents. If
he forms a new party that attracts just half of Democrats and half of independents, it
will be the largest party in America by far.

2

Table of Contents
The case for Draft Bernie is best read from start to finish. You can also click on a section
to visit it directly.
The Case for a People’s Party
1. Americans are Progressive and Want a New Party
2. The Democratic Party Remains Firmly in Neoliberal Control
3. Third Parties have Led Progressive Change throughout U.S. History
4. Turning Protests into Power
5. Sanders can Create a Party for the Progressive Majority
6. Only a New Party Can Defeat Trump and his Agenda
The Numbers
1. Americans are Progressive
2. Americans have Lost Confidence in Basic Institutions
3. The Great Shift to Independent Politics
4. The New Party’s Coalition
5. Launching the Party
6. "I Fought in the Revolution, and We Won"

3

The Case for a People’s Party
Americans are Progressive and Want a New Party
❖ Issue polls show that the majority of Americans are progressive. They want
single-payer health care, money out of politics, free public college, and much more.
❖ The majority of Americans want a major new party: 57% to 37%. In the 2016
general election, 55% of Americans wanted a major third party option on the ballot.
❖ Affiliation with the Democratic and Republican parties has been declining for a
decade and is near historic lows. Democrats account for 28% of the country,
Republicans for 29%, and independents for 40%. Gallup projects that 50% of
Americans will be independents by 2020.
❖ Gallup figures reveal an alarming trend: since the 2016 general election, affiliation
with the Democratic Party is declining while the Republican Party is holding steady,
even growing slightly. The Democratic Party is losing supporters at the time when it
should be growing most. Despite Trump’s attacks on working people and Bernie’s
monumental efforts to bring people into the Democratic Party, more and more
Democrats are becoming independents.
❖ The American people are leading the way to an independent alternative. Instead of
struggling against the progressive current in an effort to save an establishment
party, we should swim with the progressive current and create the new party that
the majority of Americans want.
❖ The political revolution has already been won in the hearts and minds of the next
generation. Millennials almost universally reject the status quo and the parties that
enforce it. 91% of people under 29 wanted a major third party option on the ballot
in 2016. People under 29 have a much more favorable view of socialism than
capitalism.
❖ The electorate is rapidly becoming even more progressive. As of 2016, Millennials
are the largest age-group voting bloc. Four years of highly-progressive Millennials
will replace four years of Silent Generation conservatives in the electorate by 2020.

4

The Democratic Party Remains Firmly in Neoliberal Control
❖ Chuck Schumer is Senate Minority Leader, Nancy Pelosi is House Minority Leader,
and Tom Perez is DNC chair. Perez has no intention of reforming the party. He was
recruited by donors to defeat the DNC chair candidates who did seek reform.
❖ In February, the DNC voted to accept corporate money and allow corporate
lobbyists to sit on the party’s national committee. In March, the DNC confirmed that
it would not support progressive candidates in primaries by withholding support to
special election candidates. In April, the DNC argued in open court that it has no
obligation to be impartial in its primaries and can pick candidates in “cigar-filled
back rooms” if it wants to.
❖ Not only has the party refused to take responsibility for rigging the primaries in
2016, it asserts the right to rig the primaries again in 2018 and 2020.
❖ Following Trump's victory, the Democratic Party is courting its own billionaires for
elected office and party leadership positions. A Goldman Sachs lobbyist sits on the
DNC. A billionaire was recently made state party chair in Florida. A billionaire coal
baron became governor in West Virginia and the Democratic Party is encouraging
billionaires in three more states to run for governor. Under the leadership of the
Democrats, the U.S. is becoming a kleptocracy.
❖ At every level, the Democratic Party is fueled by corporate and billionaire money.
This applies to the DNC, DCCC, DSCC, DLCC, DGA, ASDC and other parts of the party
organization. It pertains to the campaigns, PACs and super PACs of governors,
mayors, state legislators, members of Congress, senators and presidents. And it can
be seen in the lobbyist gifts that Democrats receive in office and Wall Street jobs
they get when they retire. The party’s politicians and staff have an establishment
worldview and work in an establishment culture. Corporate money is not a distinct,
corrupted organ of the party that can be surgically removed from an otherwise
healthy body. Corporate money is the party.
❖ During the Bernie campaign, progressives understood that taking money from the
oligarchs compromises one’s ability to represent working people. We criticized
Hillary Clinton for the millions she took from Goldman Sachs and rich donors. Now
the Democratic Party is trying to erase that understanding, lower the standards of

5
the progressive movement, and convince us that a corporate-funded party can
represent working people.
❖ Cornel West, Noam Chomsky, Michelle Alexander, Naomi Klein, Chris Hedges and
many other scholars are telling us that the Democratic Party is too entrenched and
that we need an independent alternative to succeed.
❖ Americans have a less favorable view of the Democratic Party than they have of
Trump and the Republican Party. Two-thirds of Americans say that the Democratic
Party is out of touch with the concerns of most people. More Americans believe that
Trump and the Republican Party are in touch with their concerns.
❖ In a poll of swing voters who supported Obama and then supported Trump, twice as
many people said that the Democratic Party favors the wealthy versus the
Republican Party. The Democratic Party’s brand is destroyed. Working people have
no confidence in it.
❖ Just like it did in 2016, the Democratic Party is defining itself in opposition to Trump
without offering an alternative populist platform. And just like they did in 2016,
Americans are showing that they prefer Trump to the Democratic Party
establishment.
❖ When Bernie challenged both establishment parties during the primaries, he drew
tens of thousands of people everywhere he traveled. When he campaigned for
Hillary Clinton in the general, he drew a few hundred. Not even Bernie could
convince Americans to support a Democratic Party that remains corporate. It didn’t
work in 2016 and it isn’t working now.
❖ A Democratic consultant recently summed up the party’s strategy with Bernie by
saying: “We’ll slap him over our problems but fundamentally change nothing.”

6

Third Parties have Led Progressive Change Throughout U.S. History
❖ Third parties have succeeded by either forcing the establishment parties to adopt
their platform or by replacing them outright. The current Democratic Party is free to
dismiss progressives because we lack the leverage that a major third party has given
our movements in the past.
❖ In the mid-1800s, the Liberty Party, Free Soil Party and newly formed Republican
Party pioneered an abolitionist agenda. Later, the Equal Rights Party and Eugene
Debs’ Socialist Party championed the fight for women’s suffrage. In the late 19th and
early 20th centuries, the Socialist Party, the People’s Party, Teddy Roosevelt’s Bull
Moose Party, and Bob LaFollette’s Progressive Party led the adoption of Social
Security, unemployment insurance, food and drug regulations, the 8-hour work day,
child labor laws, progressive income taxes, and the direct election of U.S. senators.
In the 1930s, Norman Thomas and the Socialist Party pushed Franklin Roosevelt
into the New Deal.
❖ Lincoln’s Republicans replaced the Whig Party in four years. It also elected Lincoln
president and took both houses of Congress in six years. The formation of the
Republican Party offers a successful model for replacing a major party in America:
progressive politicians build a large following inside an establishment party by
representing a neglected majority. After exposing the party’s inability to reform,
they take the party’s base and start a new party that replaces the old one.
❖ Americans were much more sharply divided over slavery than they are over
present-day inequality and money in politics. Yet the Republicans still replaced the
Whigs in four years. Sanders can be the Lincoln of our times.
❖ Today, the Internet enables a speed and efficiency of organizing that the progressive
movements of the past could only dream of. Digital organizing, fundraising and
independent media drove the Bernie campaign.

7

Turning Protests into Power
❖ The Occupy Wall Street movement raised awareness but failed to institutionalize
itself into a permanent electoral force and means to political power. Unless the
current resurgence of progressive marches and energy becomes permanent
institutional capacity in a new party, the resistance may recede, giving Trump
greater license in the future. Progressive energy is not being institutionalized inside
the Democratic Party.
❖ Progressives are no longer content to submit to the Democrats. But the movement is
fragmenting on the independent left in the absence of decisive leadership. This
fragmentation will continue until we move decisively into the new party strategy
that the majority of Americans want. Bernie united the movement during the
campaign and can do so again in a people’s party. No one can unite the country
under a Democratic Party that has not learned its lesson.
❖ If we stay inside the confines of the Democratic Party, define ourselves in opposition
to Trump, and fail to build our own institutional capacity, the movement will begin
to lose its progressive character. It will become defensive instead of assertive.
Reactive instead of proactive.
❖ Movements millions-strong have tried to take over the Democratic Party before:
from Jesse Jackson’s Rainbow Coalition to the anti-free trade movement of the
1990s; from the movement against the wars in the Middle East to Dennis Kucinich’s
campaign; and now, Bernie Sanders’ efforts. None have managed to reverse the
direction of the party or the country.
❖ Reforming the Democratic Party has been the progressive movement’s chief
strategy for decades. It always moves further to the right. Our movement is treading
a well-worn path.
❖ Routing the progressive movement back into the establishment parties for decades
is what got us into this mess. “Playing it safe” turned out to be extremely dangerous.

8

Sanders can Create a Party for the Progressive Majority
❖ Bernie is the most popular politician in the country and has an 80% favorability
rating among Democrats and 57% favorability among independents. His appeal with
conservatives would attract many anti-establishment Republicans to the new party
as well.
❖ A new party that attracts just half of the Democrats and half of the independents
would be the largest party in America by far.
❖ If Bernie starts a new party, we would begin with at least half of the Democratic
Party. Then we would add independents, young voters, anti-establishment voters,
the white working class, people of color, third party voters, people who have given
up on voting, and many conservatives who have a favorable impression of Bernie.
This would make the party significantly larger than what remains of the Democratic
Party.
❖ The spoiler effect leads voters to consolidate around two major parties, one on the
left and one on the right. Our new party will be the largest party on the left, leading
whatever remains of the Democratic Party to consolidate around us. The spoiler
effect will accelerate rather than hinder the new party’s growth, as the progressive
majority and everyone opposed to Trump gathers around the largest opposition
party.
❖ During the primaries, Hillary Clinton had the money, the media, the name
recognition, and the party on her side. Bernie was an unknown democratic socialist
in a country scarred by half a century of Cold War propaganda. He was successful
nevertheless because there is a force more powerful than the establishment’s
advantages in today’s politics: a revolutionary progressive message and integrity.
❖ Our movement wins when we cast out the conventional wisdom of incrementalism
and offer Americans revolutionary change. The stadiums full of supporters, the
quarter of a billion dollars he raised from small donations, and the flourishing of
supportive independent media--all of this followed from Bernie’s revolutionary
message and integrity. This is the most important lesson from his campaign.

9
❖ In a single year, Bernie started a political revolution by taking on both establishment
parties. Imagine how much more we can accomplish in three and a half years by
turning the exuberant Bernie campaign into a permanent people’s party, where we
can unite the progressive majority.
❖ By assembling the new party’s coalition, popularizing the message, and creating a
national volunteer and donor network, the Bernie campaign has effectively already
created the party. We just need to make it official.
❖ People are growing dismayed and discouraged to see Bernie remain in an
establishment party despite every indication that the party is not reforming.
Bernie’s popularity and power stem from his reputation as an incorruptible
revolutionary. That reputation will slowly fade if he continues to work inside a party
that so clearly rejects his progressive agenda. If he chooses to run for president
again in 2020, he won’t be seen as the same revolutionary figure that he was in
2016. Remaining in the Democratic Party will shake a generation’s faith in the
possibility of change within the electoral system.
❖ Bernie won’t always be here to lead the revolution. But he can give the next
generation a party that will be.

Only a New Party Can Defeat Trump and his Agenda
❖ This past November, we witnessed a spectacular failure of an attempt to defeat
Trump and authoritarianism from a neoliberal party. Since November, the
Democratic Party has only exacerbated the conditions that depressed turnout and
led Americans to support Trump in the first place.
❖ Republicans are decimating Democrats because the country is growing more
progressive on the issues. As Americans grow more progressive, they realize that
the Democratic Party doesn’t represent them and are not inspired to turn out. The
more progressive the country gets, the less motivated voters are to support a
corporate party.

10
❖ The people who need to vote in Democratic Primaries for progressives to win are
leaving the party and becoming independents, or not voting at all. The party’s
declining affiliation and favorability numbers are reiterating what we learned in
2016: opposing Trump without offering a populist alternative is the path to failure.
The Democrats are poised to continue losing and our progressive country will
continue moving to the right. An arrangement that suits the corporations and
billionaires who fund both establishment parties.
❖ Only a new party that inspires the progressive majority to vote can defeat Trump
and his agenda. Only a progressive party can take away Trump’s monopoly over
electoral populism.
❖ The business cycle is a staple of all capitalist economies. Since WWII, there has been
a recession in America about every 7 years. The country has never gone longer than
10 years without one. The Great Recession began 9 years ago, which means that,
historically speaking, there’s a high likelihood of another crash during Trump’s first
term.
❖ When financial recklessness brings down the economy again, a furious country will
scorn and abandon the parties that brought them ruin. If progressives are not
prepared to direct the public’s rage into a constructive systemic overhaul, we run a
grave risk of the authoritarian right hijacking the narrative and the mandate for
sweeping change that goes with it.
❖ If Americans don’t find an anti-establishment home on the left, people furious with
the system will rush to the only populism they see: Trump’s xenophobic,
authoritarian, and militaristic populism; just like they did in the 2016 election.
❖ It is of the utmost importance that progressives launch a populist party before such
a scenario can materialize. We must do it now, while the opportunity to carry the
revolution to the left is still open.

11

The Numbers
Americans are Progressive
Issue polls show that a large majority of Americans are progressive. They would
overwhelmingly support the new party’s platform. All figures are percentages.
Americans support:
Equal pay for women and men
Overhaul campaign finance system
Money has too much influence in campaigns
Paid family and medical leave
Some corporations don’t pay their fair share
Some wealthy people don’t pay their fair share
Allow government to negotiate drug prices
Increase financial regulation
Expand Social Security benefits by taxing the wealthy
Infrastructure jobs program
Close offshore corporate tax loopholes
Raise the minimum wage to $15
The current distribution of wealth is unfair
Free public college
Require special prosecutor for police killings
Ensure net neutrality
Ban the revolving door for corporate executives in govt
Replace the ACA with single-payer health care
Break up the big banks
Government should do more to solve problems
Public banking at post offices

93
85
84
82
82
79
79
75
72
71
70
63
63
62
61
61
59
58
58
57
56

12

Americans have Lost Confidence in Basic Institutions
Almost across the board, confidence in the foundational institutions of our society has
fallen to historic lows.
Confidence in Institutions
2004
53
30
52
41
34
46
30
30
24

Banks
Congress
The Presidency
Public Schools
Criminal Justice System
The Supreme Court
Newspapers
Television News
Big Business

2016
27
9
36
30
23
36
20
21
18

Change
-26
-21
-16
-11
-11
-10
-10
-9
-6

Put simply, these figures represent a loss of the consent of the governed. Our
government and social system have lost their legitimacy in the eyes of the public.

The Great Shift to Independent Politics
Americans are increasingly disassociating with the establishment parties and
identifying as independents. Affiliation with the establishment parties is near historic
lows.
Party Affiliation
Democrats
Republicans
Independents

2008
36
28
35

Nov 2016
31
27
36

May 2017
28
29
40

Gallup projects that 50 percent of Americans will be independents by 2020.

13

The New Party’s Coalition
A new party that attracts just half of Democrats and half of independents would be the
largest party in America by far.
Party Affiliation
Democrats
Republicans
Independents
People’s Party

May 2017
28
29
40
-

½ Dems and Ind.
14
29
20
34

Bernie’s favorability numbers with Democrats and independents suggest an even
greater shift to the people’s party. His appeal with conservatives would attract many
anti-establishment Republicans to the new party as well.
Because the new party will be the largest opposition party to Trump and the
Republicans, what remains of the Democrats and most independents would consolidate
around the new party during elections.

Bernie’s Favorability
Democrats
Republicans
Independents

Favorable
80
29
57

Unfavorable
10
61
31

Polls show that Bernie is now more popular with people of color than whites, and with
women than men.
Fifty-seven percent of Americans are asking for a major new party. How can we
revolutionize the country by disregarding the will of the people?

14

Launching the Party
If we start the party by late summer of 2017, we can get ballot access nationwide and
compete in the 2018 midterms.
● Founding convention
○ Where the movement will come together to democratically determine the
party’s platform, bylaws, name and colors.
○ A historic gathering of progressive champions, activists and cultural icons
coming together to take back the power. Makes us an instant cultural
phenomenon.
○ Progressive incumbents at all levels of government switch affiliation to the
new party, giving it instant representation throughout the country.
● Ballot access
○ Generally requires collecting thousands to tens of thousands of petition
signatures in each state.
○ Every four years, the Green and Libertarian parties collect hundreds of
thousands of signatures for presidential ballot access. They do so with far
fewer volunteers and resources.
● 2018 midterms
○ Primary data down to the precinct level tells us where Bernie’s message
performs strongest. Bernie campaign data reveals where donations and
volunteer activity were highest.
○ We challenge Republicans in lean-red districts where Bernie’s message
resonates but Democrats can’t win or don’t compete.
○ We challenge establishment Democrats in heavily-blue districts that
supported Bernie in the primaries.
● 2020 presidential
○ We run a presidential candidate. Our large majority over the Democratic
Party leads whatever remains of the party to join us against Trump.
○ Our progressive populism demolishes the Republicans after four years of
Trump, and sweeps in our down-ballot candidates in Congress and
statehouses.
○ After this election, our progressive party is the new left party in America,
having replaced the Democratic Party. Our working class majority is left with
a corporate authoritarian party as its only opposition.

15

“I Fought in the Revolution, and We Won”
Reflecting on this day, historians will note that for decades the establishment parties had
grown increasingly removed from their working class base. The final straw came in the
election of 2016, when Democratic Party bosses blocked a beloved progressive populist
during the primaries, resulting in the election of an authoritarian president. Shortly
afterwards, Bernie Sanders led progressives in Congress and across the country in
founding a new party to represent the interests of the working class. The People’s Party
quickly replaced its Democratic Party rival, marking the end of the Second Gilded Age and
the beginning of the Progressive Era four years later.

NO COMMENTS